Tudor Black Bay 58 ...

Black, but it's close. 

If you really have to, then blue, at least it looks less like a sub homage and it has a higher chance of surviving in the collection even when you will add higher-end pieces. If you already are at that point of collecting instead, and are consciously looking for a beater, fully aware of its limits but also of its perks, then go with the black and don't look back! 👍

Blue, very clear.

I don't like faultina, so the clean blue one is more my cup of tea :)

I purchased the black before the blue was available. If they had both been available when I bought, it would have been a flip of a coin, since I really like both of them. 

The blue dial version is a bit more modern looking, but there is something about the black that really appeals to me. I'm not normally a fan of faux patina, but I think it works with the BB58. 

Black for me. Just.

On a bracelet, the black gets my vote by a hair. That said, the blue BB on a blue/silver strap is one of my favorite watches. 

I chose black. But it would just depend on what I currently have in the collection. They both look great. 

Really hard choice.. I think I would go with black, but it’s a close one. 

I really like both but (today) I would go with the blue. But, it's a win win ether way. 😎

You got two wrists so zero problems 😂 

I personally love the black but I know the gilt dial is not for everyone!

Sucker for the blue😍

A thought: I bought a Seiko SPB239 62mas to scratch my BB 58 black dial and gilt vibe. It works. So, I think the black has many alternatives whereas the blue is somewhat more unique to Tudor. That being said, get what you love and for a true vintage submariner feel, the black dial does it for me.

I prefer blue. It looks clean and sporty.

I like the black - classic and versatile look.

Black, the gold tones give it warmth that I like.

I am very tempted to get a BB58 later this year. I have always thought I prefer the black, but lately the blue has been calling to me. I will have to try them on in person to really decide 

I think safe choice would be black, so i go for blue🤣

blue if i had to pick between these 2 current models

black if i could pick the prev gen ETA smiley (would be a tossup between the red and black)

Blue all day long. Faux patina and gold are two of my biggest watch pet peeves so yeah

Currently rocking my gilt dial BlackBay 58 on steel bracelet. The two things I have initially worried about (faux rivet and snowflake hour hand)  have grown on me, the only part I would change is the knurling on the crown which isn't sharp enough : difficult to get a good purcase.

Money no object, I wouldn't mind adding the blue to the collection. I've always been a fan of the Rolex Smurf 😉

This is very close for me. I really like the blue one but the colour combination of the black one is just so "iconic". I should have them first on my wrist in order to decide 😜

Thank you all… you will soon see my choice! 

Blue

Definitely the blue for me. I love especially with the blue leather strap.

ummm the Black BB58 doesn't look like sub at all.. to me

The debate is whether the BB58 should be considered a Rolex Sub homage or only heavily inspired by it. But yeah, having the same case, the same bracelet, the same dial, the same indices, the same colour scheme including the red triangle, the only difference is Mercedes hands VS snowflake hands. Quite similar I’d say 😂

EDIT: oh, and I forgot about the fake patina lume to resemble the vintage sub (which is why I suggested, if he really liked the BB58, blue may be better. Higher chances of surviving in the collection long term, unless he’s really 100% sure he‘d never have a better watch)

EDIT2: And I also forgot the fake riveted bracelet… Anyway you get the picture

Those are some NICE shots man. Blue BB58 owner here as well!
What do you mean you voted for your wallet? lol just curious

BLUE 💙

Thank you 

voted with my wallet is a term meaning I choose blue / bought blue 

Blue for me!