Redundant?

Hey Tudor fans. Just looking for your opinions if you think  these two can coexist in one collection. I realize that if the 39 is worn on a bracelet there is a bigger difference, yet I am a pretty big fan of both on straps. 

·

I don’t see why they couldn’t coexist, no different really to having a BB 41 and a BB58. Both different watches, wear differently and you can see there with the two Pelagos’s the differences in their dials.

·
Corg94

I don’t see why they couldn’t coexist, no different really to having a BB 41 and a BB58. Both different watches, wear differently and you can see there with the two Pelagos’s the differences in their dials.

Great point. Appreciate it.

·

Don't think as them as part of a collection but as two great watches and wear them a lot ,both great watches 

·

One is black and one is blue soooo different in my book … 😉

·

Yup 👍 

·
The_Watcher

Yup 👍 

Sorry, Yup they can coexist or yup they are redundant? My mistake on asking 2 questions in the post title and post. 

·

Are you asking the people on this forum???  You know the answer will be hit the gas not the brake  

·
BtownB9

Are you asking the people on this forum???  You know the answer will be hit the gas not the brake  

I suppose you could be right, but I hope most would not have a biased opinion.

·

There are people with 20 black dialed vintage Seiko divers, you're fine with a big blue and a little black Tudor. 🤷‍♂️

At least until the Pelagos 39 blue comes out 🤯

·

No, they are not redundant. One is black. The other is blue.  I have 2 divers (one blue, one black).  It works for me. 

·

I personally find them redundant. Both no date Tudor pelagos. I think the FXD is more badass and would opt to keep that one over the 39, but that's just my personal preference. I'm big on diversity within the watch collection, so I personally don't like having anything similar, let alone two of the same brand.

·
robwei

There are people with 20 black dialed vintage Seiko divers, you're fine with a big blue and a little black Tudor. 🤷‍♂️

At least until the Pelagos 39 blue comes out 🤯

Lol. That would mess things up for sure.

·

One is big and blue, the other black and little. Totally different things to me.

·

Several collections out there with multiple submariners that share more things alike than either of these two. 🤙

·

For sure, they’re different enough with the color, size, bezels, fixed lugs plus they’re both 🔥 I would keep them both…but I probably have too many divers. 

·

Really depends if one of them stops you from wearing the other