I'd go with the Steinhart. The quality of their watches is off the charts, and they are super easy to service. You can wear a 39mm Steinhart with absolutely no problems.
I am against watches that attempt to mimic every single last design element of popular watches. You will not see me wearing a one for one copy of any watch. However, I think there is a great use case scenario for exactly what you're proposing - if the homage watch has better specs than a mid to low range watch, then I'm all for the homage.
I would add one thing - the Grand Seiko SBGN027 is comparable to the BB Pro, is meant to be beaten up, has better finishing , has a 50 year service interval, and has far fewer moving parts that could wear out and costs less than the BB Pro. But of course you need to like the aesthetics too.
Spartyfan6262 hasn't earned any badges, yet.
This account is verified. WatchCrunch has confirmed that this account is the authentic presence for this person or brand.