If you have an AD that carries multiple brands I would suggest you go try some on and see what you like in person. The Oris is beautiful by the way. I would definitely go for a BB over the 1926. It also depends on your lifestyle. Since you have some dressy pieces in there do you suit up for the office every day? That's also something to consider.
I got my Aquaracer off of Walmart.com. It was a really good experience. Got it from a seller out of Japan and they were terrific.
I will say that I have bought and owned a number of homage watches. I have no problem with it, but what I find is it doesn't "scratch the itch" of wanting the original, it just made me want the original more. Keep that in mind if you are like me, it may just make the longing for the Black Bay even worse and not make it better.