Tudor
25 comments
Sort by
Brandon
Watches, whiskey, & real estate
Los Angeles, CA, USA
Member since
Last active: 23 min ago
15.24 cm
Cya pelagos!
Keep the Pelagos.
The other is a tad schizophrenic and sometimes thinks it’s vintage.
Pelagos is a more original, more authentically Tudor design
Keep the Pelagos, I take the Black Bay; oh damn you are in the US, the taxes will ruin our deal. Great watches; Congrats!
My brother in law is trying to decide which of these two will be his next purchase. Tough choice!
The one on the left looks bland.
Keep the bb58, more color is better
Pelagos for me
Pelagos for me.
They’re both great looking, I choose to keep the Pelagos but I couldn’t fault either. Lord knows I love my vintage divers.
I’d keep the Pelagos
I have the Pelagos 39 and love it, but I'd also have a BB58 in the collection too.
Looks like a tough choice, and one that could easily lead to regret. Good luck 🤞
Keep the 58!
Cya pelagos!
Yes. Can’t argue with this comment
Pelagos all day err day.
Love the 58, but the Pelagos is the more honest representation of the “modern Tudor dive watch.” Wouldn’t be where they are today without the 58, but you can’t drop the Pelagos (I prefer the blue Pelagos though).
Both Pelagos (Pelagoses? Pelagodes? Pelagi?) > BB58 IMO.
I’d pick the Pelagos personally.
Pelagos ftw.
Pelagos stays.
It depends on whether you prefer a more matte and modern look or if your taste lends to vintage style and gilt. I would personally take the Pelagos, but I like a whiter white, a square over a circle, and the light feel of titanium. That is not everyone's preference
Pelagos
Ended up keeping both. Can’t let either one go.
Keep them both 😍
Keep them both 😍
Ending up keeping both!