Keep, Sell, Trade: Dive Watch Edition
You know the rules. Keep one, sell one, trade one for equal value (within $1000). This round is for dive watches only. I’m interested to see your thoughts.
1: Rolex Submariner Date
2: Omega Seamaster 300
3: Tudor Pelagos
124 comments
Sort by
Braeden Counts
Welcome to my WatchCrunch profile.
Member since
Last active: 5 hrs ago
6.25” / 15.88 cm
Keep the Seamaster (on my wishlist)
Sell the Sub (cause it's a hype watch and rare so you can get top dollar on it)
Trade the Pelagos (for the Black Bay)
Keep the Seamaster (on my wishlist)
Sell the Sub (cause it's a hype watch and rare so you can get top dollar on it)
Trade the Pelagos (for the Black Bay)
I agree 100% with the seamaster. I’d keep the Pelagos and trade the Sub for a DateJust with a fluted bezel, jubilee bracelet and Wimbledon dial. 😂
Keep the Pelagos
Sell the Seamaster
Trade the Sub for a Globemaster.
Keep the Pelagos
Sell the Seamaster
Trade the Sub for a Globemaster.
Sell the Seamaster? 😢😢
Keep Omega, Sell the Rolex, and trade the Tudor for a Grand Seiko
Keep the Seamaster cos it's the most interesting to look at
Sell the Sub (lots of dosh for a plain black watch)
Trade the Pelagos for absolutely anything
Keep Omega, Sell the Rolex, and trade the Tudor for a Grand Seiko
Which GS?
Keep the Seamaster cos it's the most interesting to look at
Sell the Sub (lots of dosh for a plain black watch)
Trade the Pelagos for absolutely anything
Absolutely anything huh? 😂
Keep Tudor, trade Rolex, sell Omega. This will maximize value and returns.
Keep the Pelagos,
Sell the overpriced sub.
Trade the SMP for a speedy!
Too easy.
Keep the Omega, sell the Rolex, trade the Tudor for a used terracotta Aqua Terra.
Keep Tudor, trade Rolex, sell Omega. This will maximize value and returns.
So you trade the Crown and sell the Omega. What are you trading for and what are you buying?
Interesting take! Tell me more?
Keep the Pelagos,
Sell the overpriced sub.
Trade the SMP for a speedy!
Too easy.
I like the way you think! I don’t think it’s easy though. 😂😂
I like the way you think! I don’t think it’s easy though. 😂😂
It was for me!
Trade them all for a Fifty Fathoms...
This one...
Or this one...
Keep the Pelagos, sell the Omega, trade the Rolex for this Grand Seiko
Keep the Seamaster
Trade the Sub for a no date Sub
Sell the Pelagos
Keep Omega, sell Tudor and trade Sub for used Fifty Fathoms
Keep the Pelly (own one now and it’s arguably one of my fav watches of all time)
sell the seamaster and probs use the funds for the SMP 300 or speedy
Trade sub for a YM or SD!
Trade them all for a Fifty Fathoms...
This one...
Or this one...
A gentleman and a scholar. Great taste in divers!!
Keep the Sub, it is an icon and for my wrist, wears best of the three.
Sell The Omega
Trade the Pelagos for a Pelagos FXD, largely because I do not want to get rid of the Pelagos. Might be one of my favorite watches at any price point.
Great breakdown and wouldn’t be mad if I did a similar choice. I love my Pelagos 42 and as much as I love a sub, my heart years for a pre ceramic sub or ideally a birth year sea dweller!
It depends.
If you want to make $: sell the Sub, keep the Omega, trade the Pelagos for a BB58.
If money is not an issue: keep the Sub, sell the Pelagos, trade the 300 for a 300 Professional
Keep the Pelly (own one now and it’s arguably one of my fav watches of all time)
sell the seamaster and probs use the funds for the SMP 300 or speedy
Trade sub for a YM or SD!
You my friend are a genuine genius
You my friend are a genuine genius
Much appreciated good sir 🤘🏼
Keep the Pelagos. The titanium looks sharp with the blue dial.
Trade the Seamaster for the 41mm Aqua Terra. I like the design better, and it still has a James Bond connection. Daniel Craig wore a blue one in a couple of movies. However, I lean slightly towards the green one.
Sell the Submariner. Too flashy and too mainstream.
Keep the Seamaster
Sell the Submariner
Trade the Pelagos for the Planet Ocean 8500 37.5mm
Keep the pelagos, sell the sub, trade the omega.
I love the pelagos so..
Sell the Rolex (of course)
Trade the seamaster for a pelagos 39
Keep the blue pelagos
Honestly, neither of these watches resonates with me. I would keep the Seamaster, but I don't know which one I would sell and which one trade. Probably trade the Pelagos for a CW Bel Canto or a Grand Seiko Heritage and sell the Submariner.