"Downgrading"

Sorry for another one of these subjective discussion posts, but this is where I'm at.

I think I want to let go of my Aqua Terra and get a Formex Essence. This would free up some extra cash so I can try other watches, like a Zelos, another Monta, Farer, Henry Archer, or CW. I've been having a blast trying smaller microbrands and appreciate the creativity, innovation, and value most of them offer.

It seems like a good decision, because:

1) I prefer the more rugged/aggressive tool-like design and increased legibility of the Formex

2) I like the engineering feats it demonstrates

3) it has a usable bracelet (sorry Omega, yours isn't)

4) I wouldn't feel like I'm getting ripped off from a big conglomerate owning a Formex

So all is well, I do it then, right?

Not that simple. For some reason in the back of my head I think "why would you DOWNGRADE for a lesser watch?" Sounds crazy, right?

Maybe it's because prestigious brand image and marketing is such a big part of the watch industry/hobby as a whole. I'm in my twenties, going to college, have nothing to show off, but am incredibly enthusiastic about watches – that doesn't mean I NEED to OWN Tudor/Omega/Rolex... right?

Curious to hear all your thoughts.

·

How long would you have to wait to buy the formex outright, without selling the AT? That would be very useful in determining if selling the AT is truly something you're okay with, rather than just a fast track to getting the formex you want right now. If you genuinely have issues with the AT, then it's less risky to sell it, but I'd want to be very confident I'm not going to want it back before selling it. Formex does make nice stuff, so I think that side of the equation is pretty sound.

·

A major part of me takes exception with the part that Omega is ripping people off.

Nothing wrong with microbrands but their "value" is largely overstated. The whole "we cut out the middle man" is an exaggeration. If a brand doesn't have dealers they have to have more staff, plain and simple. So they are really just shifting (and maybe slightly) reducing cost. Not eliminating it. Their movements are also not theirs and are lower quality than an Omega Coaxial, so again more the illusion of savings compared to actual savings.

Add to all of that the lower resale for microbrands down the road. The ironic thing is the only reason that what you are proposing is even possible is because the Omega holds it's value so well.

·

One of my favorite posts here by @Orontius_Fineus talks through the act of "downgrading" in a very mature, measured way. Worth a read.

·

The bottom line is this, it’s your money and your watch, you do what you want to do. That being said, you indicated that you are going to college, my advice would be to be careful that you don’t over extend yourself and leave yourself short on money. I have a lot of younger adults at work asking me watch questions and a lot of them have had issues with microbrands. I’m not saying this would happen to you, but it’s worth thinking about. Omega in my experience is an outstanding watch company and as long as you care for your time piece you will likely be able to pass it down to your children. If you are having issues with your bracket you can always get a different one, this can be a cheap way to change the look of the watch and it’s comfort, I’ve done this on a lot of my watches. In the end it’s your money and you should do what you want with your money. I wish the best of luck with your decision.

·

It’s amazing you already have an AT in your 20s. I just got my pre-owned one a month ago. Does the AT have any sentimental value? If so, keep it. I also really like the Formex and agree the Omega bracelet is meh. Value is relative though and your journey is your own. I wouldn’t necessarily think of it as a downgrade or anything.

·

I'd say keep the AT !

·

No comparison. Formex is fine. But the AT is an amazing and timeless watch. I fear you will regret it and you’re just being pulled to buy the other watches to have a “collection”

·
parechute

If AT is attached to some special event or achievement, like graduation or you worked very hard to buy it, you should keep it if you can. You will thank yourself decades later.

I bought JLC Master Geographic 24 years ago, which was the first mechanical watch I bought with my own money. Since then, I bought and sold quite a few watches and there were times I didn’t wear Geographic for years. I thank my past self for not selling it when it felt boring because I started loving it again.

Image

I'm so glad you came back to it. Just shows how our emotions change over time

·

I understand that you want to try new things but it is far more likely than not that you will one day regret selling the AT.

·

I wouldn’t sell the AT. With how the watch industry works, it’ll probably cost most at msrp two or three years later and you’ll kick yourself if you have any seller’s remorse

·

Let me offer another crazy idea. This sounds like a great reason to give yourself a push. Make a project/business to earn the money for the next watch. You might actually earn your next career on the way!

·

Owning an AT and having handled and being familiar with the specs of the Formex (which I like quite a bit) I do think the AT is a lot more watch. Maybe not dollar for dollar, but my AT is my travel watch because of how robust and functional it is. And the metas movement with extra WR (and screw down crown) just give me a lot of peace of mind.

If those things don’t matter to you then go for the Formex.

·

Nothing wrong with downgrading. Not sure I'd do it for a Formex specifically, however, as it's always sounded like a condom brand to me. But in general, sure, why not?

·

I've wanted to try on the Formex for some time. I'm going to NY watch event in October to try on a bunch of these brands to answer these precise questions. If it gives you the same/better feeling and wearing experience then do it. I'd just be careful because the cost to get back into the AT if you change your mind might cost you more in the end should you change your mind.

·

I have both the AT and a Formex. Keep the AT and just save for the money for the Formex. Get a new strap for your AT so you can enjoy it again. Sometimes they just need a refresh to remind you why you liked or loved it in the beginning. The money spent for it is already gone while selling sounds like a good idea now - rebuying down the road will not feel good.

·
Patrik2

Im not sure I agree, an aqua terra is what, 4-5-6 thousand us dollars? My zelos cost 500 and has all the bells and whistles you could think of with exceptional finishing and attention to detail. It is also more rare than any omega could be.

The AT is a fine watch but is it 8-10 times better because of the better accuracy by a couple of seconds?

Rarity doesn't equal valuable

·
Meglos

Rarity doesn't equal valuable

Thats true, but it is a plus, at least for me.😃

·

If it suits you, go for it. Sell the AT and experience other brands. You can always purchase another AT in the future again.

·
Jrodst1050

It seems like "you are looking for permission" from a bunch of strangers. You know better than anybody else your finances. If you need to sell your Omega AT to fund your new Formex and other watches, Do it!!! You can always buy another Omega AT in the future if you change your mind. It is your life journey into horology, make the best of it!!!

Have you not read much of this forum? Half the posts are asking permission to do something/asking what people should do, from a group of randoms, ie: us. I find it quite weird, personally, and would never seek advice like that. But I guess it helps some folks!

·
complication

Have you not read much of this forum? Half the posts are asking permission to do something/asking what people should do, from a group of randoms, ie: us. I find it quite weird, personally, and would never seek advice like that. But I guess it helps some folks!

Yes I read the heading, "like you should", and advises at the bottom. Some people recommended to keep the watch and others to sell his Omega Aquaterra to fund his endeavors. The last time I check this is an"open public forum" and everybody is entitled to their own opinion. Unless we are living in North Korea. Last time I check we are not! Cheers! 👍

·

Keep the Omega

·

Bought a Formex Essence a couple of months ago and love it. I no longer feel the need to add an AT to my collection despite it previously being a sort of grail of mine.

The AT is considered by most as the better watch and it is certainly much more recognisable and prestigious. The Essence keeps time to a second or two per day, IMO has excellent finishing, a wearable bracelet (with a sort of micro adjustment clasp) and a very interesting dial.

·

I would keep the aqua terra, or if you have fallen out of love with it then perhaps sell it and get something on equal footing.

The micro brands are great I have a few and I love them. But the general person on the street is always taken by a premium brand option.

Id keep at least one premium and then have a flutter on the occasional microbrands rather than trying to just do it all in one.

But that's just my two cents

·

Keep the Omega AT. The watch industry isn’t going anywhere so I don’t see why you’d sell such an amazing watch to fund the purchase of some microbrands.

·

No do not. Why rush to downgrade? Generally people don't downgrade. If anything they would sell or trade up. So you are definitely going the wrong direction IMHO

·

I think you're crazy. Stick with the Omega.

Microbrands might look more appealing on the exterior, but ultimately the Omega is technically far superior - so much more R&D budget. More accurate, better finished, better after-sales support.

The conglomerate thing? Honestly, you've already sunk the money, all you'd be doing in this plan is lose more money on depreciation of the Omega. Then lose more money as the Formex depreciates even more than the Omega. Before you've even realised you've made a mistake, you'll be $1500 worse off than now..

To me, the only reasonable point you had was about the bracelet? I'd try to solve that issue before looking at alternatives.

·

I would just buy the rubber band for the Omega. I think on that configuration it's one of the best looking watches out there. If I can get over the thickness I will buy one myself. I have been thinking about getting a Formex Essence 39 for a while but something about it feels off. The bezel is quite thick, the date window is a mile wide... I don't know. It just doesn't do it for me.

The bracelet of Omegas aren't great but then again that's true for most bracelets in my opinion. Is the Formex an upgrade in that regard, I doubt it. What I don't doubt is that the Formex is a downgrade in terms of overall execution and movement technology. The Omega is more expensive for a reason.

·

I think “downgrading” is the wrong word for this. It’s just shifting to another watch. The AT is more expensive and has more brand cache but I it’s common for watch people to buy and sell with some frequency. If you can enjoy the Formex AND another watch today with the money you free up, I’d say go for it. We all have limited resources and unlimited watches we want, so do what you have to in order to experience as many as possible. You can always come back to the AT later.

·

Just a heads up, the Formex suspension system is a hair plucker. Traded my Formex essence 39 for that reason as well as a misaligned chapter ring. When I went to the store to look at their Malachite edition I noticed it had a misaligned chapter ring as well

·
timetrapper

No do not. Why rush to downgrade? Generally people don't downgrade. If anything they would sell or trade up. So you are definitely going the wrong direction IMHO

There is always a first.