Keep Saving?

Morning Cruncher’s! Having a decent watch collection I am looking to buy my statement piece (for now) which will be my first blue dial. All the others are white/black. And I have narrowed my options to a shortlist of 2. The VC overseas or the ISC ingenious. Both look amazing although they have different aesthetics, VC is more dress oriented and IWC is tooly. The question is, buy the IWC or continue to save for the VC? Or other?

·

I love IWC as a brand, but the VC is the statement piece. There’s a lot to like in the Ingenieur (that dial texture for example), but I think the VC is the complete package. Patience is a virtue.

·

Vacheron. No question.

·

VC.. not doubt..

·

VC my favorite out of the big 3. When they make 222 in steel it will go crazy

·

VC is all in one . 3 straps fit all situation. No doubt , VC pls

·
kinobro

VC my favorite out of the big 3. When they make 222 in steel it will go crazy

I’d be in for that.

·

Between the VC and the IWC? The VC.

Between me and my wallet? The blue dial Seiko SNXS77 😬

Image
·

The VC looks the best but how much is the service cost? Are you ok to pay it? A guy on here earlier said his A Lange servicing was 3-4k$.

The Ingenieur looks good but the internals are the same as the pilot if I recall. If you don't care about internal movement value bang for buck then get the Ingenieur. You can always trade up later.

·

I just added a VC Chrono blue dial to my collection. I got mine from "LV Luxury" Vacheron AD in Las Vegas, Erin there is awesome to deal with, she kept me updated by text and wait times were short. Also she will help you will save a little bit of money.

·

VC, any day ,every day and twice on Sunday

·

I'm just here to drool. The VC ultimately wins overall, of course, but both are knockout designs at their respective levels.

·

Vote for VC from me over here! Versatility, trinity piece, still somewhat unique in its design with the Maltese cross links, and a huge saving to be had if buying pre-owned!

·

I love the Ingenieur, but the Overseas has a much nicer blue dial. The Ingenieur looks better with a white or black dial in my opinion.

·

I don't like textured dials, but there's lots of other things to prefer about that VC - it wins hands down in my book.

·

VC

·

What kind of statement do you want to make? I am curious.

·
Just_My_Pinion

I dont think these watches are that comparable. There are a number of things that put them in different classes.

But there is a general rule: Dont settle. The Inge would only make me want the VC more.

Buy Inge if that is the one you want. Based on your post, it isnt. Save up

Of course they are comparable. There is no barrier that prevents a comparison.

·
Just_My_Pinion

The common movement in the Inge is what keeps the cost down for service. You can service it at any watchmaker.

Unless there is something special about the movement, in house movement is not a huge benefit to me

Doesnt the Ingeneur share the same movement with the Mark XX and the B&M Clifton? I didnt know that it is considered a common movemen.

·
Hans01

What kind of statement do you want to make? I am curious.

It’s more of a personal statement to myself. I have bought a lot of watches in my time and have quite a bit of buyers regret stored away. Mostly from pulling the trigger to early and not taking my time to really consider. This would be me saying to myself that I can forgo short term pleasure for long term gain. The journey is just as valuable!

·
daiKel

May I…

Image

Looks better than both and has the more interesting movement.

·
Smurray74

It’s more of a personal statement to myself. I have bought a lot of watches in my time and have quite a bit of buyers regret stored away. Mostly from pulling the trigger to early and not taking my time to really consider. This would be me saying to myself that I can forgo short term pleasure for long term gain. The journey is just as valuable!

A good statement to have. I applaude you.

·

The blue green dial is amazing

Image
·
Hans01

Doesnt the Ingeneur share the same movement with the Mark XX and the B&M Clifton? I didnt know that it is considered a common movemen.

From SJX:

“Though it’s larger and has a longer power reserve, the BM12-1975A is derived from Cartier’s 1847 MC movement, explaining the similarity in components and layout.”

So Ingenieur, Mark XX, Riviera, Clifton and a bunch of Cartiers. This is a good thing in terms of serviceability.

·
Hans01

Of course they are comparable. There is no barrier that prevents a comparison.

One definition of comparable is “of equivalent quality”

These are both Richemont watches at different places on their tier.

·
Just_My_Pinion

One definition of comparable is “of equivalent quality”

These are both Richemont watches at different places on their tier.

This doesnt prevent a comparison. Then we see how comparable they are.

·
Just_My_Pinion

From SJX:

“Though it’s larger and has a longer power reserve, the BM12-1975A is derived from Cartier’s 1847 MC movement, explaining the similarity in components and layout.”

So Ingenieur, Mark XX, Riviera, Clifton and a bunch of Cartiers. This is a good thing in terms of serviceability.

So thats what you mean with common movement, I get it. When I think about common, I have a ETA/Sellita in mind. Also, didnt know that Cartier uses this movement as well, nice to know.

·

If you’re looking for an under the radar every day tool, I would be buying the IWC with the black dial. If you want a statement piece that is maybe a little less every day casual and rugged looking but dresses up better I’d be going with the blue dial VC. This blue dial is a great color by IWC, but if it has to be a blue dial I’m probably still saving up for the VC.

·

VC

·

If you can get the VC I’d go with that. Class!

·

Thanks everyone for commenting. It’s a tough one definitely, and a lot what has been pointed out has gone through my mind. I will keeping saving and visiting my local dealers for a view until I make mind up. I can’t get past the vc dial but want the iwc price 😂 one I have something in hand I’ll make sure to post some photos. 👍🏻