MoonSwatch thoughts, and seeking strap advice

I've had mixed feelings about the MoonSwatch ever since it was announced, but wanted the opportunity to be able to handle one in person so that I could discover for myself what all the fuss was about. I live in a small city without a Swatch boutique, and I didn't care enough to expend time and effort to find one, or to pay over retail. When I had the opportunity this week to pick one up at MSRP from a friend in the local watch community, I decided to jump on it. If I had been able to choose, I would have selected either the Mercury or Jupiter versions, but I didn't have any options, and ended up with "Mission on Earth".

I was actually pleasantly surprised by the watch itself. I had read and heard so many negative comments about how cheap and plasticky it was that my expectations were really low. It turns out that it's actually not as bad as I had been led to believe.

From what I've read, some people have reported getting brand new watches with the plastic crystal already being scratched, so I was pleasantly surprised that mine was absent of any noticeable scratches. Given that the crystal is plastic, I suspect that scratches could become an issue, but I understand that they can be polished out with a Cape Cod cloth (apparently PolyWatch isn't sufficient).

One of the things that drives me nuts with quartz watches is having the seconds hand not line up with the markers, and I've seen several videos of the MoonSwatch where that appears to be a huge issue. Once again, I was lucky in that mine seems to line up reasonably well for the most part.  

I suspect that these issues speak to the quality control (or lack thereof), with me just being lucky enough to receive a sample where those weren't major issues.

Another negative frequently cited is that the light weight makes the watch feel really cheap. There is no arguing the fact that this is an extremely light weight watch. It weighs in at only 33.3 grams including the Velcro strap, and a mere 22.5g for the watch head itself. The light weight by itself didn't translate directly into a cheap feel for me personally, especially considering the sharpness of the case contours. I had expected the watch to feel like a toy, but while it obviously lacks a premium feel, it doesn't feel any more toy-like than my CasiOak G-Shock. If anything, I find the extreme light weight to be a positive aspect of the watch.

One of the obvious draws of this watch is its resemblance to the real Speedmaster Professional. Other than the location of the chrono pushers, the case is indeed similar to the real Speedmaster Pro.  Although the sub-dial placement is obviously different, it certainly is reminiscent of the real deal. The actual functionality of the chronograph itself is also different, providing a maximum of 60 minute timing (versus 12 hours for the Pro), but also showing fractions of a second when the chrono is stopped. While nobody is ever going to confuse it with a real Speedmaster, there is no doubt that it does have a similar vibe. 

Now that my curiosity has been satisfied, I don't expect this watch to see significant wrist time, but I intend to keep it as part of my collection of Speedmasters and will likely wear it occasionally. As a fan of the Speedmaster, I think that the retail price can potentially be justified, however I don't think that it represents great value. For budget conscious collectors, the price would be tough to justify unless the aesthetic appeals sufficiently, especially considering that it is essentially a disposable watch that's not designed to be repaired. In a world where people will pay multiples of MSRP just to get a Tiffany blue dial variant of an OP, paying the premium over other Swatch watches with a similar movement in order to obtain a watch with the iconic Speedmaster appearance doesn't seem terribly out of line. That assumes being able to buy at retail without having to go out of your way to get it. Paying over retail, or wasting hours of your precious time to get one at retail, just doesn't seem to be a wise thing to do, but that's just my opinion.

With all that said, one of my main issues with the particular variant that I ended up with is trying to find a decent strap to pair it with, as everything seems to clash with the green used for the case color. I currently have it on an old  black Zelos rubber strap that I had kicking around, but ideally I'd prefer to find some type of fabric strap with colors that would complement the weird case/dial colors. If anyone can offer some suggestions for an appropriate strap, I'd really appreciate it.

Image
Reply
·

I have a Jupiter, and came to much the same conclusion. It's a fun watch at retail, but not worth a penny more. 

I agree WRT the value as well, it isn't "worth" retail on specs, the case shape, and the official tie-in with the Speedmaster are what gives it the value. If someone doesn't value those two things, buy a Pagani copy, it even has a date complication. 

·

Welcome the review & spot on regarding the value. 

WRT the strap, what about a brown to match the hands?

·

Blue sailcloth or nato will likely work - something as dark as the blue on the bezel.

·
UnholiestJedi

Welcome the review & spot on regarding the value. 

WRT the strap, what about a brown to match the hands?

I was thinking about that, but the brown of the hands is really subtle, and the mint green case is so "in your face", that I think it would require the perfect shade of brown. I tried placing the watch against the brown straps that I have available, and none of them looked right (but then again, the black strap I'm using doesn't look great either). If I can find the perfect brown, I think it could be  great choice.

·
bevelwerks

Blue sailcloth or nato will likely work - something as dark as the blue on the bezel.

Thanks - that reminded me that I had a black Artem sailcloth strap that I had picked up for another watch. I just tried it, and I think it's an improvement over the black rubber Zelos strap I had been using. The Artem web site shows a navy blue version as well, but it's hard to tell from looking at the web site whether or not the shade of blue would work with the dial/bezel or not. I'm sure I could make use of the navy blue strap on another watch anyway, so I may give that a chance. The mint green is such a difficult color to work with - not sure what they were thinking.

·

Oh wow, the subdials are a little different. Thanks for helping me tell these apart a little.

I dunno, maybe a Marine Nationale type thingee. I'd honestly just use whatever came on the other Omegas. It would fit, right?

·
PoorMansRolex

Oh wow, the subdials are a little different. Thanks for helping me tell these apart a little.

I dunno, maybe a Marine Nationale type thingee. I'd honestly just use whatever came on the other Omegas. It would fit, right?

The visual differences may be subtle, but they can have a substantial effect on the overall look of the watch. The devil is in the details.

I had hoped that the Marine Nationale strap that I got with my Seiko Flightmaster would work, but the different greens clash like crazy. I haven't found any on line that would appear to work, but I must say that type of strap is extremely comfortable.

·

Thanks for sharing your thoughts.

Been fortunate enough to pick up two. IMO they look best on a fitted black rubber strap. Failing that I found that the silicone straps for a Samsung smartwatch fit pretty good. They can be picked up on eBay for around £2.50 each. Come in a variety of colours, quick release and a tuck under clasp

Image
Image
·
Chunghauphoto

Thanks for sharing your thoughts.

Been fortunate enough to pick up two. IMO they look best on a fitted black rubber strap. Failing that I found that the silicone straps for a Samsung smartwatch fit pretty good. They can be picked up on eBay for around £2.50 each. Come in a variety of colours, quick release and a tuck under clasp

Image
Image

Thanks for the suggestion - I'll check them out.

·

Ok sorry for the rookie question here but what is the deal with a moonswatch?