Review: Ball Engineer III Marvelight Caring Edition

Unless you don’t know anything about Ball or The Marvelight caring edition, I recommend you skip brand and model and go straight down to wearability. 
 

The Brand:

Image

Following a head on train collision in Kipton, Ohio, which killed 8 people, local jeweler, Webster C Ball was commissioned to create the Rail Road Standard Time. Due to the extreme accuracy of his pocket watches, the term, “Get on the Ball” was born. 
 

Ball nearly disappeared as a brand in the 2nd half of the 20th century, and was reborn in Switzerland with a new focus on mechanical tool watches and with a unique design style. Ball is a leader in the use of Tritium as a source of illumination, incorporated into the aesthetic in a sometimes magnificent way, but sometimes quite tacky. No matter how you feel about their use of tritium, it gives a nearly one of a kind presentation. 

The Model:

Image

The Engineer III line seeks to be a technological upgrade with enhanced sophistication over the popular Engineer lines (engineer II and M), mostly using tritium tubes as single indices throughout the collection. Most of the line is quite neutral in its presentation, featuring simple white tubes that radiate a soft green color in the dark. The Caring Edition, is something quite different, quite polarizing, in fact. The 12 indices show a rainbow of 6 colors, with corresponding indices on opposite sides of the dial. The white, red, green, blue, red, and yellow are somewhat muted in natural light only giving off a hint of the fireworks by outlining the tritium tubes in the color reference of the tritium glow. The minute markers correspond to the color way with a negative display that is imperceptible in full light. 
 

The dauphine hands are a high polish silver with their own tritium types to illuminate the night, and the counter-balance on the second hand is an extremely stylized RR, reflecting the history of Ball watches. All this illumination, color, and detail is set against a matte black dial with three lines of branding at the 12 o’clock and two lines of text at the 6 o’clock. The date is set at the traditional 3 o’clock position, with yet another controversial addition, the cyclops.

The case is reminiscent of a Rolex Oyster Perpetual in shape and finish. The rounded sides  move elegantly to the lugs for a strap monster width of 20mm. Just like the bracelet, the case is completely finished in 904L steel, giving it additional shine. The stew in place H links are satin finished with the protruding center links being  a high polish. Once again Ball made this bold design choice that isn’t part of their normal Engineer III Marvelight collection. The signed screw down crown and train engine in relief finish out the historical call back of the brand. 
 

Image

The Wearability:

Image

This watch wears well!  It is quite comfortable and well proportioned, if not a tad tall. The greater than 13 mm thickness of the watch isn’t noticeable thanks to the down sling lugs and rounded case architecture. The pull butterfly clasp is definitely a low water mark in the luxury department. It’s high quality, and easy to fit to the wrist with the additional half links, but the mechanism is of a much lower price point. The legibility of the watch is without fault with the dial, hands, and indices visible in all lighting conditions against the matte black dial and easily viewable through the AR coated sapphire crystal. Even the cyclops has its advantage here. The COSC ETA movement is run of the mill, but dead on accurate. The screw down crown aids in the 100m water resistance, while the anti-shock mechanism and 1000 gauss anti-magnetism make is a true go anywhere, do anything sports watch. 
 

The Owner:

Image

Who is this watch for?  Well, it’s for me!  I am a Biochemist spending much of my day in analytical chemistry laboratories, surrounded by instruments and dangerous caustics and corrosives. Working in a laboratory, the first thought is always safety, calling back to the founding of Ball Watch. The anti-magnetism is important for working with the instrumentation and the COSC certification aligns with the constant instrument calibrations we must perform before testing. The 904L steel stops the watch from rusting and the screw down crown keeps the vapors out of the watches inner workings. The tritium is a cool chemistry vibe, and because I helped to develop the Covid vaccine, and the Caring edition was launched to give us hope during lockdowns, this was and is the perfect watch for me!

Review: Ball Engineer III Marvelight Caring Edition

4.4
Yes No
4/5
5/5
5/5
4/5
4/5
  • Legibility
  • Specs/Tool/Use Case
  • Contradiction in sophistication vs fun
  • Polarizing
  • Clasp
Reply
·

Thank you for the work you did on the Covid vaccine. 👏👍

Awesome watch! 

·
Predneck

Thank you for the work you did on the Covid vaccine. 👏👍

Awesome watch! 

Well, we thought it was going to work better than it did. 🤷

Regardless, it was a pinnacle project in my line of work and I wanted to celebrate that fact with a watch fitting the effort. 

·

You work at Pfizer or Moderna?  You were working with messenger RNA?   Just curious.  I’m on the other end of the system in the ICU.  Nice review, and watch.  I’m not into ball but this particular model appealed to my love for color and ‘pop’ from a watch.  Had no idea it was the ‘caring edition’.  Cheers 🍻  Still have to buy myself something nice  to celebrate surviving those few years of hell!!

·

Thank you for your service, and for this detailed review! 💪

·

I have #402

·

Thanks for my introduction to Ball! Cool historical ties and I love that it is a perfect watch for you.

·

Great review And it sounds like it’s very deserving to be on your wrist. Thank you for your hard work these past years!

·
Wingking75

I have #402

Mine’s 394. 

·

Pre-ordered the Caring Edition at MSRP straight from Ball back in 2020. Had survived COVID prior to vaccination and had watched hundreds die in our COVID ICU. 
 

Was my first step back into more expensive watches. Arrived in 2021 and the rotor spun with every winding. Insanity. So off the watch went to the AD service center for warranty repair. Took 3-4 months to get it back. 
 

When the watchmaker called me personally to tell me NOT to wind the watch as they had seen a glut of Ball models come in with the same issue and that Ball was having quality issues with their movement modifications, that was the end of Ball for me. 
 

Sadly I sold it and will not buy another Ball model. They are overpriced at MSRP but I won't touch them at grey market now. 
 

Hope yours does well but be aware. 

·
biglove

Pre-ordered the Caring Edition at MSRP straight from Ball back in 2020. Had survived COVID prior to vaccination and had watched hundreds die in our COVID ICU. 
 

Was my first step back into more expensive watches. Arrived in 2021 and the rotor spun with every winding. Insanity. So off the watch went to the AD service center for warranty repair. Took 3-4 months to get it back. 
 

When the watchmaker called me personally to tell me NOT to wind the watch as they had seen a glut of Ball models come in with the same issue and that Ball was having quality issues with their movement modifications, that was the end of Ball for me. 
 

Sadly I sold it and will not buy another Ball model. They are overpriced at MSRP but I won't touch them at grey market now. 
 

Hope yours does well but be aware. 

Thanks for the input. That’s a strange issue for such a standard ETA movement.  Have had mine for seven months and it is flawless. Winds perfectly and keeps time to +/-1 second/day. 

·

Thanks for the detailed and interested review mate, amazing watch, it suits you very well, also thank you for your work on the COVID vaccine!

·

Nice review and thanks for your work. I work on monoclonals, an early, but now mostly supplanted therapy. Glad for the vaccines! I have 2 Ball watches, I have had quality issues with both, but they are interesting additions to the collection with the tritium lume. Glad yours is working well! 

I agree the butterfly clasp is of lower quality than the rest of the watch on my Trainmaster MSF. Overall the titanium bracelet had a very rough finish.  I’ve switched the bracelet to a NATO, and now like the watch much better.  My Trainmaster 120th Anniversary needed two warranty services for accuracy, but now is running well. It’s a beautiful watch.

Image
Image
·

Thank you for your review. I've been thinking about a Ball Watch as my first luxury piece and specifically a rainbow lume in 904L steel.

Also, thanks to @Robcollects and @biglove for their input. I had not heard about quality issues on these watches yet. I'll certainly take this info into consideration.

·

Thanks for your insightful post.

·

Wow. I’ve never seen this one before. I think I’m in love! This is definitely a “me” watch and going on my list. Thank you!

·

Not gonna lie -- the multicolor thing is cool!

·

Is tridium safe ? If it is why most watch makers in Switzerland and Germany are not using them, especially Rolex ?

·
Spiderman88

Is tridium safe ? If it is why most watch makers in Switzerland and Germany are not using them, especially Rolex ?

It is safe when not ingested in large quantities. Tritium is stored in tubes in watch faces now and reacts with phosphorous to create constantly radiating light.

The reason more don’t use it is because placing it in a tube limits your design.