How I got into watch collecting, and how Stuhrling and Ben's Watch Club helped me find WatchCrunch!

So I was working on my "About" section today, and I thought: Why not make this into an actual post? People love good stories!

Plus, the "About" editor doesn't allow paragraph spacing, or text formatting of any kind. It just kinda' crams all the text together in one, tight block.

So I figured I would make a post, so that I (and others!) could see the stories as they were meant to be seen, with proper formatting.

So without further ado...

How did you first get into watch collecting?

I bought my first real watch (a Citizen Promaster 200m WR Model 5502) in the mid-1990s, because I wanted a nice, reliable, watch to wear, which would be of high quality, and last a lifetime, which I could hand down to future generations. (I was single at the time, marriage was still 10 years away, but I did eventually give that watch to my son, on his 13th birthday.)

When I first got married, my wife gave me a Marc Ecko watch for Christmas (2005), which was a real piece of jewelery; the bezel was completely encrusted with Cz, making the watch stunning to look at. (Years later, I found out that the movement in that watch was a SEIKO-Epson/Hattori Y121E. That's a really decent movement for a fashion watch!)

Image

Since by that point, I didn't really wear the Citizen watch anymore, I began wearing the Ecko watch as my main, daily timepiece. I would say that at this point, having two nice watches in my jewelery box, I was officially a watch collector; in my mind, you just need to have more than one watch to be a collector.

The third watch was a Stuhrling Original, Concorso Raceway Model 564.02, which was another gift from my wife, this time, for Valentine's Day 2014.

Image

I got a fourth watch for Christmas 2021 from my parents: a Tissot Classic Dream. At that point, I had already given the Citizen to my son the previous year, so the Tissot was really watch #3 in my collection.

Image

Then, during the Christmas season of 2022-2023 (i.e., between Dec. 25, 2022, and Jan. 06, 2023) my son started asking me about watches, because his collection was starting to grow, and he wanted to really understand what he had. I had already given him a pocket watch (years before), in addition to the Citizen dive watch, and he also had a Casio "Arnie" that my dad had given him, and a Timex Ironman that his Taekwondo instructor had given to him (and all the other assistant instructors) so that they would all have watches with timers and stopwatch capabilities, which they needed during the course of training exercises.

Additionally, he had bought himself a G-Shock with his own money. He asked me if he should keep them all, or sell some of them; I told him that he should keep all of the ones that were gifts, for sentimental reasons (and in the case of the Timex, for practical reasons; his instructor expects all assistant instructors to wear that watch during every class) and that he could sell the G-Shock, since the Ironman was basically the same watch.

But he didn't want to sell the G-Shock, because he was proud of the fact that he had bought it himself, with money that he had worked hard to save. So he ended up keeping all the watches.

That's what gave me my inspiration; I figured that having a collection of watches was a neat thing. My son had twice as many watches as me, but when I looked at his collection, I found myself thinking: I can get him a couple more this year, for his birthday, and for when he finally gets his 3rd degree black belt.

And then, when I looked at my own, small collection, I thought: I should grow my watch collection as well. And BOOM! The bug had bitten! The lightning had struck! I suddenly found myself shopping for watches! I bought two watches for my son, two for myself, and two watches for my daughter as well. I even bought my wife a watch for Valentine's Day, a Stuhrling just like the one she got me, so that we could be matchy-matchy! And the craze has not waned, but rather, strengthened in its ferocity. Cheers! 🍻

Do you have a watch with a particularly interesting story behind it?

My Stuhrling Concorso Raceway (Daytona homage) was a gift from my wife, for Valentine's Day in 2014. Recently, during Christmas season of 2022-2023, while I was helping my son research and learn more about watch collecting in general (see above), we ran across a YouTube video from Ben's Watch Club (@benswatchclub) that was trashing the Stuhrling brand. 🤣

My son got upset, because he knew that I had a sentimental attachment to my Stuhrling, but I calmed him down, and said, "Look, we can agree to disagree. My watch looks great, has lasted 9 years, and has / still does keep extremely accurate time. Nothing he can say will ever change those facts. And besides, mom and I have a rule about never spending more than $75 on gifts for minor holidays, such as Valentine's Day. So he's probably right about the build quality, at least to some extent."

Upon hearing this, my son said, "Yeah, I guess I can see that." And that's when I said.... "Hey, change of subject, why don't we check out that watch forum he mentioned at the beginning of the video? What was it called....? Watch...club? No, WatchCrunch!"

AND THAT IS THE STORY OF HOW MY SON AND I FOUND AND JOINED WATCHCRUNCH BECAUSE OF A BAD REVIEW OF THE STUHRLING WATCH BRAND. Hahaha. 🤣😎

Reply
·

Great story, thanks for sharing, and it enforces it is more often about the experience than the brand. Just about everyone here got into the hobby with the likes of Invicta, Sturling, Fossil, etc. Nothing wrong with that at all, as we grow in the hobby tastes get refined, we begin to understand comparable value, but in the price range those brands play in, have at it all day long.

·

great story 😂. thats sounds like a ben lol

·

That’s a great story. It’s great you’re sharing the experience with your family. My kids love tinkering around on my pile of spare watches, they’re really fond of using the press.

·

Also got here through Mr.Ben 🙂 His reviews are great, but remember - he mostly reviews new watches. Some brands might have produced good “value for money” pieces 10 years ago (like watch of yours), but price-value proposition deteriorated over time and now they produce crap …

·
WatchObserver

Also got here through Mr.Ben 🙂 His reviews are great, but remember - he mostly reviews new watches. Some brands might have produced good “value for money” pieces 10 years ago (like watch of yours), but price-value proposition deteriorated over time and now they produce crap …

I've actually heard the reverse--that they used to be hit or miss, but nowadays, have improved somewhat. But who knows? Without buying a bunch of Stuhrling watches and testing them all?

·

You’re right, we’re suckers for watch-related stories, thanks for sharing. I’m hoping watches are something I can share with my kids as they grow, but time will tell.

·

Concerning the "build quality" complaint, I am always a bit suspicious when reviewers complain about that, i.e. often it seems that's how they try to rationalize their negative emotions about a watch (brand). That is: unless they indicate a concrete thing that was build badly. They would never criticize Seiko about poor build quality, but they would complain about its misaligned bezels, markers not being hit, etc. Go figure.

·
uhrensohn

Concerning the "build quality" complaint, I am always a bit suspicious when reviewers complain about that, i.e. often it seems that's how they try to rationalize their negative emotions about a watch (brand). That is: unless they indicate a concrete thing that was build badly. They would never criticize Seiko about poor build quality, but they would complain about its misaligned bezels, markers not being hit, etc. Go figure.

Probably the best post I've read for a while.

·

Welcome to WC! Now that's an intro 👍

·

For me this a wonderful Father & Son story.

Thank you for sharing.

·
The_Timist

Welcome to WC! Now that's an intro 👍

I've actually been here about a month and a half, I just never did (until now) completely fill out the "About Me" section. 🙂

·
uhrensohn

Concerning the "build quality" complaint, I am always a bit suspicious when reviewers complain about that, i.e. often it seems that's how they try to rationalize their negative emotions about a watch (brand). That is: unless they indicate a concrete thing that was build badly. They would never criticize Seiko about poor build quality, but they would complain about its misaligned bezels, markers not being hit, etc. Go figure.

To be fair, a lot of Ben's criticisms were spot on; I think, in its early days, Stührling was trying perhaps a bit too hard to get noticed, making a lot of flashy claims (Swiss founder, etc.) that couldn't be proven. Whether this was intentional (gosh, I hope not!) or whether this was just repeating family legends out of ignorance (I think most likely) is not entirely clear. In my review of my own Stührling watch, I noted this. What saves Stührling, at least from my perspective, and personal experience, is their excellent customer service. Thus, they actually scored "mid-tier" on my company reputation rubric that I created. If you'd like to see my review, look at this post: https://www.watchcrunch.com/TwiceTollingClock/reviews/stuhrling-original-concorso-raceway-model-no-564-02-review-26371

I gave them 3 out of 5 for quality, 2 out of 5 for movement, and 3 out of 5 for design; so I didn't go easy on them. But all in all, for a watch that cost $75.76 ($69.99 + 8.25% Sales Tax) it is actually a decently-built watch. But as @OscarKlosoff noted in the comments section of my review, their "hucksterism" turns a lot of people off. And I said as much also, noting that "Stührling should stop pretending to be old and established, and just focus on making good watches."

But one thing we should all take into account: every company embellishes a little. All companies have ad agencies and marketing firms, whose sole mission is to make the company look as good as possible to the public. Hype is everywhere. I just think that Stührling took it a little too far. And recently, they have backed off a little on some of that hype. They have now openly admitted that most of their movements are sourced in China. So, I am willing to cut them a little slack, as long as they don't backslide. And like I said, my own watch has held up well over my 9 years of ownership, and I think actual use and real-world testing is the true test of any watch, in terms of quality.

·

I love my stuhrling. Works great. Looks good and keeps perfect time. For the money you can't beat it.

Image
·
elliotb

I love my stuhrling. Works great. Looks good and keeps perfect time. For the money you can't beat it.

Image

I love that strap you have it on! It matches the color of the dial quite well, and looks super-sporty! 😀

·

Great straps at great prices. Customer service is outstanding

https://campionato.club

·

wow..that Daytona Stuhrling....