Most Overrated Iconic Watch

To follow the lead of the most episode of About Effing Time, I wanted to create a poll to determine the watch we watch nerds feel is the most overrated. All of these 4 watches are absolutely icons, but are they overrated? And if so, which one is the most overrated?
93 votes ·
Reply
·

I chose the omega Purley because they keep trading on the fact it went to space,

·

The Submariner and Speedmaster maybe the most boring watches but not overrated. They still serve a purpose and good watches for the price. They both have history of being created for a purpose.

The Royal Oak and Nautilus both run on the same train but the 5711 is one of the most overrated watch, a stainless steel watch being traded for ridiculous price and personally not a fan of the dial design or the hands. I would pick a Royal Oak as it has something more going for it in terma of the dial and the overall watch being better.

·

Anything Genta from the 70's onwards. Genuinely find the whole style a case of "Emperor's New Clothes".

And the Speedy shouldn't be on the list - it's the only one with any real achievement & imho the most iconic watch ever made ( no I haven't got one & wouldn't want one )