Which Tudor ? Pelagos FXD or Black Bay 54 ?

I like both watches, but which one should go for ? One is all about vintage style and the other about new materials and a modern interpretation of a vintage Tudor Submariner .
105 votes ·
Reply
·

Such different watches. Depends what you like for size and also Bracelet/strap options

·

Oof, that’s tough. I go back and forth between the Pelagos and BB58 all the time. I think they’re different enough it’s hard to compare them.

That’s not very helpful is it?

·

Pelagos, especially the FXD, all day err day.

Apex predator.

https://www.watchesofespionage.com/blogs/woe-dispatch/tudors-of-espionage

·

I had to choose between my FXD and Pelagos 39. For me the FXD won hands down. The low lying lugs and fabric strap make it crazy wearable for a 42mm watch. The fully graduated bezel looks so good and is more useful. The military link is cool as it makes it feel more purposeful..

·

Buy them all. I'm stupid enough to try.