Which Tudor ? Pelagos FXD or Black Bay 54 ?

I like both watches, but which one should go for ? One is all about vintage style and the other about new materials and a modern interpretation of a vintage Tudor Submariner .
109 votes

Such different watches. Depends what you like for size and also Bracelet/strap options

Oof, that鈥檚 tough. I go back and forth between the Pelagos and BB58 all the time. I think they鈥檙e different enough it鈥檚 hard to compare them.

That鈥檚 not very helpful is it?

Pelagos, especially the FXD, all day err day.

Apex predator.


I had to choose between my FXD and Pelagos 39. For me the FXD won hands down. The low lying lugs and fabric strap make it crazy wearable for a 42mm watch. The fully graduated bezel looks so good and is more useful. The military link is cool as it makes it feel more purposeful..

Buy them all. I'm stupid enough to try.