Help!! Which one to sell?

If you only can have 3 watches, below are here to stay, which will you choose to sell? Rolex or Cartier?

Image
95 votes ·
Reply
·

Given the total lack of context.....

Image
·

Um why do we need to sell…if you absolutely have to I think the Cartier has to be the choice

·
foghorn

Given the total lack of context.....

Image

My apologies, i have updated the description. Please help!

·
BtownB9

Um why do we need to sell…if you absolutely have to I think the Cartier has to be the choice

Because both are bright dial, which somehow overlap.

·

I’m just afraid rolex will come out with a new 40mm Polar.

·

You never know if rolex is gonna to remake a new 40mm polar. The current 42mm is too big.

·

Tough call.

·

Im actually prefer watches that have design language which is cartier. In fact, i find myself in love with the tank americane as well. But i find myself picking up the polar more often due to its wearablilty.

Image
·
palicar

Tough call.

Exactly when they both overlap in term of dial color

·

I think as i grow older, dress watch or vintage watch is hitting me hard.

Image
·

Yes, i think vintages are something more rare than those hype watches.

·

yea, i just sold this recently. Would have kept it if it 36mm. 34mm is kinda of small for me.

Image
·

I happen to found one like yours, but its a next iteration after yours. What is a good price to enter?

·
thewatchdonut

I’m just afraid rolex will come out with a new 40mm Polar.

Why afraid?

·
phillylawyer

Why afraid?

Then the value of this will eventually dropped. I didnt bought it that cheap tbh.

·

Tempting…

·

How about cal 853?

·
thewatchdonut

Exactly when they both overlap in term of dial color

I voted Cartier even though it gets points for being unique in shape, brand, style, etc. The Explorer 2 has enough presence to stand apart from the VC and the other Rolex while rounding out a cohesive identity of confident class in the 3 watch rotation. The Santos sticks out as flaunting it a bit more than the others and, by comparison, doing so garishly. You know, in my opinion. ✌️

·

That Explorer (not the II) would be gone in a second.

·

Noted that. Let me analyse

·
palicar

I voted Cartier even though it gets points for being unique in shape, brand, style, etc. The Explorer 2 has enough presence to stand apart from the VC and the other Rolex while rounding out a cohesive identity of confident class in the 3 watch rotation. The Santos sticks out as flaunting it a bit more than the others and, by comparison, doing so garishly. You know, in my opinion. ✌️

Tough tough tough.

·
AllTheWatches

That Explorer (not the II) would be gone in a second.

It stay. Inexpensive and versatile watch

·
thewatchdonut

It stay. Inexpensive and versatile watch

You do you. For me, there are better and more versatile in the price range, but that is me.

·

Gmt = fad. Let it go.

·
thewatchdonut

Then the value of this will eventually dropped. I didnt bought it that cheap tbh.

Nah you’ll be fine

·

Nobody can tell you what to buy or sell, that's entirely up to you.

Your decision is the only one that matters.