Same same?

So here we have two that are variations on a theme. Both dive style watches with caller GMT. Both 42mm cases. Seiko is twice the price of the Steinhart.

Steinhart has a longer lug to lug and wears thinner but the curved shape of the seiko case makes it hug the wrist. Both are comfortable but in different ways. Finishing is higher level on the Seiko, but build quality doesn’t feel different. At least not to me.

Wondering what people like more. I’ve got them both and for both are getting wrist time. But I think I like the seiko better even though wearing the Steinhart is more comfortable for me. I like the dive timer bezel in addition to the GMT function.

Seiko by a lug!

·

I have a below-average wrist size, and even I can wear the MM200 despite its large 42mm diameter and 49mm L2L distance. The lugs curve perfectly to fit the shape of my wrist and there is no overhang whatsoever. It's a brilliant case construction and the alternating finishing techniques is the cherry on top. 😍

On the other hand, I had to sell the Hamilton Khaki Field Mechanical. Despite a shorter L2L distance of 47mm, the lack of curvature on the case made it overhang on my wrist and looked terrible.

·

Seiko looks better IMO.

·

Seiko for sure...the prospex Seikos are superior to the entry level ones.

·
UnholiestJedi

Watches are fast moving into (if not already there) look & feel over value for the most part. Value is sometimes overrated.

Similar specs, similar build quality, yet the Seiko is liked more, even though (or because?) it's 2x the price.

Sure, value is a consideration, but really above a certain price point (different for everyone) that should only be so if one is comparing watches with similar price points or movements.

If I could afford either of these watches and they were under consideration, I'd just pick the one I liked more over the one that provided better value.

My opinion & as always YMMV.

MTFBWY

And what's value defined as? Your definition of value is not the same as mine, is there any official definition? What's the value of an obsolete technology such as mechanical watch movements?

·

Ocean gmt is much easier on the eyes. I like that watch alot