I just turned 50 and got myself a gold datejust 1601. I shouldn’t have waited this long - and trust me when I say that even at 50 you are not going to look old. You need to get into your 70s for that. Having said all that the vintage gold tends to be more warm and less aggressive and the leather strap says your soul is a part of a different time. I would dress it up with a well cut shirt - long sleeves work great and wool trousers, preferably brown. If you want to look like an older gentleman you need to think about the full look - not just what’s on your wrist. Enjoy it, but more importantly enjoy life!
I have two categories in my spreadsheet on this topic. One called Dress Traditional and the other called Dress Casual. This falls under dress casual I think.