Which one should I buy?

Factors to consider:

  • 16cm (6.3 inches) wrist

  • Iโ€™ve only had quartz watches so far

  • I have no real need for either functions: diving or to track multiple time zones.

Any reasons are welcome ๐Ÿ™

Thank you โœŒ๏ธ

63 votes ยท
Reply
ยท

I would encourage trying them in a Seiko boutique if you can, as both of these wear quite differently than their dimensions might suggest.

The SKX case design is big and top-heavy but with short lugs (42mm diameter, 46mm L2L) making it easy to wear on smaller wrist without overhang. But due to that big size, it will still have a lot of presence on the wrist and look like a big watch. If you don't care for the GMT function, I would highly recommend looking into the SRPK line instead, which are a 38mm scaled-down version of the iconic SKX design and might look better on your wrist overall. The 38mm SRPK also comes with a narrower 20mm bracelet which greatly reduces the visual bulk of the watch.

The Solar prospex is exactly the opposite. It's a 38mm diameter case that looks small on wrist, but with longer lugs proportionally (46.5mm L2L) so it looks elongated and could overhang slightly on a small wrist.

My wrist is 16.5cm but rather flat and I can just barely pull off the 48mm L2L of the SPB187 and the 46mm L2L of the SKX007. If I had to do it again today, I would buy a 38mm SRPK instead of 42mm.

ยท
Beanna

I would encourage trying them in a Seiko boutique if you can, as both of these wear quite differently than their dimensions might suggest.

The SKX case design is big and top-heavy but with short lugs (42mm diameter, 46mm L2L) making it easy to wear on smaller wrist without overhang. But due to that big size, it will still have a lot of presence on the wrist and look like a big watch. If you don't care for the GMT function, I would highly recommend looking into the SRPK line instead, which are a 38mm scaled-down version of the iconic SKX design and might look better on your wrist overall. The 38mm SRPK also comes with a narrower 20mm bracelet which greatly reduces the visual bulk of the watch.

The Solar prospex is exactly the opposite. It's a 38mm diameter case that looks small on wrist, but with longer lugs proportionally (46.5mm L2L) so it looks elongated and could overhang slightly on a small wrist.

My wrist is 16.5cm but rather flat and I can just barely pull off the 48mm L2L of the SPB187 and the 46mm L2L of the SKX007. If I had to do it again today, I would buy a 38mm SRPK instead of 42mm.

Sound advice, thank you.

ยท

Those are 2 great choices. But I agree that its best you drop by your Seiko AD to try out different watches. Thereโ€™s a ton to pick! Literally. Enjoy the journey!๐Ÿ˜Š

ยท

I second the motion of @Beanna

ยท

Seiko Solar on a LongIsland Jubilee.

The perfect take on what a modern day sub should be. YMMV.

Image
Image
ยท

I have 6.25โ€ and this is how my SRDP looks on my wrist comparing to CW 63 Selander (39mm).

Then a side comparison of the 2 watches.

However, it is best to go to an AD and try for yourself.

I prefer my CW.

Image
Image
Image
ยท
nickwt8

I have 6.25โ€ and this is how my SRDP looks on my wrist comparing to CW 63 Selander (39mm).

Then a side comparison of the 2 watches.

However, it is best to go to an AD and try for yourself.

I prefer my CW.

Image
Image
Image

Thanks, Nick.

Whatโ€™s the case size of your Seiko and respective lug to lug lengths?

ยท
burntleaves

Thanks, Nick.

Whatโ€™s the case size of your Seiko and respective lug to lug lengths?

Case Diameter is 42.5 mm

Lug-to-lug is 46 mm

ยท
nickwt8

Case Diameter is 42.5 mm

Lug-to-lug is 46 mm

I still havenโ€™t pulled the trigger. Thanks again for sharing your preference and sizing comparison.