Conversion
It’s not going to happen very much at all, if ever, to most of us. But let’s just ask the hypothetical anyway: if you were approached by a non-hobbyist-normie with some curiosity at your wrist, wondering what to get, and had only a couple minutes to chat—how would it go?
This happened to me once. It was at my first meetup that i happened to host as well. There were five of us nut jobs getting together that day, just a simple little lunch and a bunch of nerding. Our server came up to us at the end and asked what was going on, he seemed interested, chatted a bit and eventually got to ask, “Which one should I start with?” That golden sentence every one of us want to hear out loud by the uninitiated, the phrase we all look forward to and will probably hear once if at all. Your mileage may vary of course, if it does happen to everyone regularly, then I’m wrong again and we move on.
At that moment of us hearing that question, I’m pretty sure we assaulted the poor guy with way too much geek energy. There was probably some kind of synchronized smile from the five of us, and then went on like a troop of chimps. By the time we calmed ourselves down enough to make some kind of intelligible sentence, we maybe ended up saying something about a Timex. Probably lost that fish, but we got a bite at least.
It’ll never happen again, maybe i dunno, but if I were to think about it, prep myself, hash out the bullet points for a slide presentation; I might consider taking a more relaxed route than my first chance. If i were to have a crack at it again, i might do my best to tell them this first: don’t start collecting. Find one and wear it for at least six months, a year if they can. Their first pick might be important, i can’t just say, “bUY wuT YeW LikE! PEACE!” That’s just unhelpful and potentially bad advice. I can’t just fire a recommendation out of the gate and leave it at that either. That’s just self indulgent, and i wanna make sure they’re given the information with their personality in mind. I’ve gotta ask about them. Gotta ask what they do. What they like. How seriously do they take fashion. All that might entail what a watch for that person means, not just me and my thoughts of what I’d want for my first watch, or what I’d want to give a watch nerd, or what I’d want my progeny to inherit. In plain, basic, simple terms i would do my best to get across what I’m getting at—just get one, wear it.
I would forget about all that history and provenance nonsense, and I’ll be damned if i’m gonna shill a smartwatch—but if they’re dead set on it, who am i to stop anyone (i’m guessing a couple hobbyists have joined because of them). If they say their budget is unlimited, I’d still only recommend something under a hundred—everything else is superfluous. There’s absolutely zero necessity to encourage someone to buy a Patek because they can afford it and it’s what they like. And for the love of all that is holy I’ll keep them away from vintage. In all likelihood I’d barely cover the topic of movements and steer them toward quartz or solar.
That’s what i might try and do next time. If’n.
Yeah, that's a tough one. You need to find out their lifestyle plus what they can afford and feel comfortable spending on a watch. A lot to unpack before recommending something.
https://youtu.be/Ch1buU797lA?is=WTHGCl9DIuc9WcyL
Ohh I like this question, I really love a Seagull 1963 as a first watch recommendation. In it's various iterations, different sizes, optional sapphire, optional swan neck. Panda is my personal favourite. It's mechanical, it's hand wind, it's fun, it's good to look at, it's got an amazing history and most of all, it's cheap!
Not for everyone but I do think if someone is interested in the hobby it's a good place to start.
First you ask, what are you looking to spend? They’ll answer $x.xx and then you reply “check out Seiko”. The end.
I've had this question not long ago from a dude who wears a Garmin day to day and is very outdoors and camping focused. He seems to hugely prefer black PVD coated and large-ish dials but I only found this out by pretty much interrogating him and showing a few pieces to him. Additionally, the awkward questions popped up of what his budget was. He wasn't wanting a dress piece, really did like dive watches and seemed to hone in on the photos of my Luminox BO3121 but wanted ideally something British. I ended up directing him to take a look at two models with Stirling Durrant and two with CWC. He's taken the plunge on one of the Stirlings.
I think maybe the general key is to not overly bamboozle with too much choice and pin them down to answering when they're wearing it and the activities they'll be engaged in. Also, try to not sell them YOUR taste.