Achenar
Mike
Achenar
Mike
Recent posts
Homage, Clomage, Replica, and Franken... Thoughts?
Recent Comments
Counterpoint:
After everything I have done, seen, and learned, I am inclined to agree with you 100%. The problem is 20/20 hindsight. What you described is the destination, and not the journey... at least not the one about going from knowing nothing about watches to being an enthusiast, or, in my case, being so obsessed you start building your own watches.
Your advice here in this comment is top notch, and is absolutely the correct path: Figure out your budget, and buy a solid watch you love in that bracket, or, if you are dead-set on a grail, buy and f91w and save. But that is not how everyone works, and everyone's journey is different. Sometimes, certain people have to make mistakes to learn from them, and realize what it is they really want. In my own case, I can tell you experiencing DG18->Miyota8215->Seiko NH35->Miyota9015->ETA 2824->ETA 2892->Omega 2500.... is an experience I would not give up for the world, because I now appreciate the Swiss movements SO MUCH MORE.
I could have followed your advice... I certainly heard it back then, but I wouldn't appreciate my Omega quite as much as I do now without that journey, and the learnings that came with it... and that was worth the few hundred dollars I burned over the last 6 years (recouped some of it). My journey made me so well versed in movements that friends regularly ask me to verify authenticity and condition of watches.
So, ya, you are 100% right, and that is the advice I would give to any watch enthusiast, brand new or legacy... but I also understand everyone learns in their own way, and sometimes, a small taste of your grail is what gets you locked into to actually attaining it one day.
1) No, the name is not the main issue. San Martin has the same issue, despite the unique name: they are a Rolex clone house, though they at least have started to make unique designs.
2) Using Pagani was very likely intended to get more audience traction. Did it work? Well, Pagani design certainly has a better ring to it than Phylida, which sounds like an STD, or any other random assortment of English characters other companies use.
3) Not super familiar with Czapek, but at current, they seem fairly independent... I wouldn't even call them an homage brand. Ya, they jumped on the integrated bracelet band wagon, but I think they are sufficiently unique, at least with what I saw.
ROLEX: Rolex is it's own beast that is the Ferrari of the watch world in terms of business practice, brand protection, and customer relations. Unlike other watch brands, part of the Rolex value is rarity, though it is manufactured rarity. A Rolex Submariner is probably legitimately worth maybe $6000. The other $4000 is for the manufactured exclusivity, which is why they are worth more on the second hand market. But, much like Ferrari, part of that brand presence is ensuring some knuckle head doesn't clap out their product, which is why they are so selective on their clients, and why flipping an allocation will get you blacklisted.
Nautilus v royal oak: Again, you are conflating homage with clomage, in an effort to run defense for the latter. No one is critical of real homages here. The conversation is based off the example you originally listed, which are clomages, so the nautilus vs royal oak argument does not apply... they are sufficiently different from each other.
On you final statement, I really have no idea what you are getting at. The majority of clomage owners wear it because they like the design but can't justify the price of the genuine.... but I know of no such owner that proudly proclaims they are wearing a clone... at least not in the U.S.A. (people in certain other regions I have met seem proud to have saved 90%, but seemingly don't understand the reduction in quality). So, no, I don't see any of them "owning it." As for the genuine IWC owner, well, my coworker who has one seems pretty happy with it, and is proud to have that piece of horology, so, if I think I understand what you are trying to say, I emphatically disagree.
Kind of wish you kept the AI version, as this took me a second to understand. Regardless, a couple notes:
Not sure if you are aware, but Pagani Design has nothing to do with the Pagani family or the hyper car... There is no one at this Chinese watch company named Pagani: they stole the name just like they stole their designs, and, in fact, have a subline with a different name specifically to sell in Europe due to issues with using "Pagani" there.
Again, not 100% sure on your intent, but it sounds like you are sort of trying to wave away the clomage criticism of these companies by suggesting the customers are watch enthusiasts, and clomages can help bring people into the watch world. I would counter with the assertion that two things can be true at the same time...
It is absolutely true that clomages, on a purely effectual level, do indeed draw in many enthusiasts into the watch world. I always loved the Seamaster because of Goldeneye, and the N64 game based off it, but it never occurred to me to actually get the watch.
During the pandemic, a Watchfinder Co. comparison video about the latest Seamaster and a very close replica intrigued me: I couldn't believe how close Chinese copies had progressed. That led me down the rabbit hole to other watch content creators like Just One More Watch, which in turn led to me looking at aliexpress. Now, I never bought a Seamaster clomage, but I did buy a cheap homage (Seamaster like, but hands were more Seiko, the dial was enamel, and the bracelet was oyster style), and that watch really made me want the Seamaster. Eventually, this led to a purchase on an actual Seamaster, so, in a weird way, that "copy" got a sale for Omega.
Now there are tons of stories just like that, and they are always fun to hear, but that does not detract from the reality that these clomage companies absolutely are "stealing" their designs from the RnD work of another company. Now that is legal (Watch brands do not generally get patents on visual watch designs because they are notoriously difficult to defend and enforce), but it is still riding the coat tails of the work of others. Now, you can decide whether or not that is ethical, but I would not diminish that as reality. As @English_archer said, just own it.
Me personally, I really don't care. As I have mentioned in previous posts, I don't think a clomage, or even a replica, has ever stopped a sale of a Rolex or Omega. Some people want an original, quality Swiss watch. Some people cannot justify the cost and just want the look. And some people buy both: The primary watch, and a beater version. But I believe there are precisely zero people who were on their way to an Omega boutique, and then cancelled their order because they found a cheaper clomage. So while the likes of Pagani Design are stealing other companies' homework, I do not believe they are in any way taking sales away from said company.
This uses a standard two button pusher deployment style clasp. I ordered two, and one of them would only latch one of the pushers. The deployment clasps are also available on their own from AliExpress/Amazon for a few bucks. The reason they are so inexpensive, as opposed to, say, a $85 Tissot deployment style clasp, is because the manufacturing tolerance is not nearly as good, so the error rate is likely MUCH higher.
Mine won't lock entirely and yours has too much metal, not allowing it to open. You can probably file yours down, but I would just buy a few more deployment clasps... one of em should work.
It can be done, but you will need to measure the stem height, and find a case that is the same or taller, and use spacer rings in the latter case ( pun INTENDED :P). Most cases will be designed for an ETA 2824, ETA 2836, or an NH35 (I believe the Miyota 8215 is the same as the 2836)