You hit the nail on the head - I want both watches, or at least I want the SBGE257 and a watch that fits the role I envision the BB58 filling. Several have suggested a cheaper watch to fill that slot, and I agree, there should be something cheaper for an everyday/beater. Problem is - I just haven't found one that draws me in. 

Something about the aesthetic. The Seamaster has a more modern look, has contrast between high polished and brushed links, the dial is very flashy. I just don't envision that looking as good with years of yard work and BBQ scratches. 

The BB58 already leans into the retro styling, all brushed rather than polished. I think some wear marks will eventually "fit in" a little better. 

I haven't thought of one that fits, though I agree that there certainly should be something that fits that bill for less! Throw out your suggestions. 

Yeah, it's no longer a dress watch. If that's what you are wanting it to try to become, you're going to be disappointed. If you can view it as a fun casual/every day watch (I'm getting Omega Aquaterra vibes) then I think you can grow to love it. But a blue rubber strap on it if that's the direction you want to go. 

Wait - who are you kicking out??

Your Speedmaster has been one of my considerations. I agree - I think my next watch needs to be a black dial that I can wear with anything - swim trunks or a suit. Something I can have for life and something that can take some scratches over that time. Because of that, I know I can't go with a hessalite speedy, but those sapphire ones start to get so expensive that I consider waiting. 

Really I think the Black Bay is what I need - I had about decided to buy it - but then I started overanalyzing - I like date functions, it doesn't have one. I hate the snowflake hands, and the bracelet has some complaints. 

Really what fits all the requirements is a sub. but I can't swing $14K with the markets killing us and the possibility of a diamond ring purchase coming up. 

Unfortunately for the Doxa, I hate cushion cases. 

I always like to have a watch that holds SOME value, but if it has some depreciation, I'm fine. I look at the net profit/loss and then factor in what I'm paying to wear the watch while it's in the collection. 

Even losing several hundred dollars for many wears over the course of the year is better depreciation than you get from most goods. 

The couple Rolexes I've lucked into help finance other purchases and enjoyment in the hobby.