mkpwe1

MKP

0 Posts
0 Followers
0 Following
Follow Following Following
1 year ago
Joined
6.50” / 16.51 cm Wrist

Recent Comments

commented on JLC Master Ultra Thin Moon (39 vs 36) ·

Wanted to chime in with my 2c. For everyone saying 36mm as the traditional size, I would agree with you 99.9% of the time, but for the MUT the 16mm lug width makes it very disproportional. It would be absolutely perfect at 18mm, but they decided they want to try and make this for women in a way that ensures this watch's target demographic was absolutely nobody by making it 16mm lug width on a 36mm case. It looks fine when you take pictures above the wrist, but when you look at it from the side or any other angle, it just looks silly. The strap that the 36mm comes with doesn't even wrap around my 6.5 inch wrist. The boutique said I would need to order a custom strap because they don't make straps long enough as it's geared towards women. (yes, I know the 36mm is a men's size and I 100% agree. This is just how JLC is positioning it)

commented on 36 vs 39 JLC Master Ultra Thin Moon side-by-side ·

Believe it's a 16mm vs 20mm lug width difference. This obviously isn’t an exact science, but one way to think about it is that going from 39 -> 36 in case size is roughly a 7.5% decrease in size, whereas going from 20 -> 16 in lug width is a 20% decrease in the width. It's clearly not a proportional change. A good frame of reference is the 35–37mm range from Patek, where you’ll consistently see lug widths of 18mm or more.

commented on 36 vs 39 JLC Master Ultra Thin Moon side-by-side ·

Just wanted to add a +1 for the 39mm if we really had to choose one. While the 36mm is case in isolation is the better designed case, the 16mm lug width is really disproportionate. It’s a shame because the 39mm does wear quite large for what it is. What’s confusing really confusing to me is that 36mm is actually the traditional men's size for a classic dress watch, yet here it seems JLC Is positioning it as a women’s piece with the lug width and strap length despite it being a bit too large for that audience. The 39mm leans more modern but starts to lose the elegance and balance expected in this category. I can't help but feel like JLC is unintentionally alienating both both camps with this model. Making this at 36mm with 18mm+ lug width is the obvious choice.