kirito

Kirito

3 Posts
0 Followers
0 Following
Follow Following Following
1 week ago
Joined
Uttar Pradesh, India

Recent posts

You guys are fast! Pivoted based on your feedback from earlier today. Went full Neo-Vintage Salmon Sector. Targeting $429. Better?

Hey WatchFam, 👋 Thanks for the brutal honesty on my concept post from earlier today! You were 100% right—meteorite is getting a bit overdone, the GS...
11 comments

Switched up the dial to a deep midnight blue sunburst! Would love your thoughts on this Caelan Cross 38mm concept

Hey WatchCrunch family! 👋 Huge thanks to everyone who checked out my last concept. After getting some great feedback on dial textures and making thin...
10 comments

Working on my first microbrand concept - 38mm Meteorite dial & Blued Hands. Would love your honest feedback!

Hi WatchCrunch family! 👋 I’m a long-time watch nerd taking the plunge into designing my own microbrand watch. I’m calling it Caelan Cross . I wanted...
20 comments

Recent Comments

commented on You guys are fast! Pivoted based on your feedback from earlier today. Went full Neo-Vintage Salmon Sector. Targeting $429. Better? ·

Will you tell me that does it genuinely worth $429 or not?

commented on Working on my first microbrand concept - 38mm Meteorite dial & Blued Hands. Would love your honest feedback! ·

Thank you all for the amazing feedback! I'm seeing a very clear theme in the comments: 'It looks like a Grand Seiko homage' and 'Meteorite is overdone in the microbrand space.'

Honestly, being compared to GS is flattering, but I hear you loud and clear on needing a stronger Unique Selling Point (USP). @ericwn and @sam_kula make a great point—if I want to stand out from catalog AliExpress builds, it needs its own distinct soul.

I'm going to take a step back and rethink the dial material. Maybe a fumée dial like @Inkitatus suggested, or exploring different indices/hands configurations to move away from the generic GS look. I really appreciate you guys taking the time to guide a newcomer. I’ll take this feedback, work on proper CAD designs next, and come back when I have something truly unique. Cheers!

commented on Switched up the dial to a deep midnight blue sunburst! Would love your thoughts on this Caelan Cross 38mm concept ·

Wow, lesson learned! 😅 Thank you everyone for the brutal honesty. You are all 100% right. Blued hands on a dark blue sunburst dial completely destroys legibility. I got too caught up in trying to match colors and completely forgot the main function of a watch—telling the time. I will definitely be swapping these to high-polished silver/rhodium hands so they actually pop.

To address the elephant in the room regarding the renders (especially @xxDCxx and @SwedishBones): You guys have incredibly sharp eyes. To be completely transparent, I am very early in the conceptual phase. I've been using AI tools and Photoshop composites just to visualize colorways, dial textures, and general vibes before I spend thousands of dollars on proper engineering CAD files and physical prototypes.

I'm a beginner taking my first steps, and I clearly made a rookie mistake today. The early logo resembling Chanel was an oversight that I'm actively redesigning. I appreciate the tough love—this is exactly why I came to this community. I want to know what fails before cutting real metal. Back to the drawing board for this one!

commented on Working on my first microbrand concept - 38mm Meteorite dial & Blued Hands. Would love your honest feedback! ·

Thanks a lot! Wow, being compared to Grand Seiko is a huge compliment. Really appreciate you checking it out!