eutoolwatch

eutoolwatch

1 Posts
3 Followers
1 Following
Follow Following Following
5 months ago
Joined

Recent posts

Sub-€1000 field-grade tool watch project — looking for honest feedback

Working on a tool watch project in advanced prototype phase. Pre-launch, stealth phase during legal review. Build: - Grade 2 titanium · matte black re...
29 comments

Recent Comments

commented on Sub-€1000 field-grade tool watch project — looking for honest feedback ·

@sam_kula — likewise. Thanks for pushing the thinking. 🍻

commented on Sub-€1000 field-grade tool watch project — looking for honest feedback ·

@725auto — my respect, good piece.

commented on Sub-€1000 field-grade tool watch project — looking for honest feedback ·

@725auto — thanks for that, good to hear.

On solar I did look into it, but four things ruled it out

for this version:

1. Accuracy — no solar movement available for

microbrand use reaches ±20 sec/year. Citizen's highest

solar calibers do, but they're reserved for in-house

Citizen models, not OEM.

2. Sourcing — the strong solar movements (Citizen

Eco-Drive, Seiko Solar) are kept proprietary by their

makers. What's available to microbrands is mostly

±15 sec/month class, not the precision tier I needed.

3. Torque for tritium — the original plan was tritium

tubes on the hands. Tritium hands are heavier than

painted ones and need a movement with enough torque to

drive them cleanly, which narrowed the options further.

4. Tritium dropped for v1 — licensing tritium in my

country is extremely complicated, and international

shipments with radioactive material add friction down

the line. Tritium is something we want to revisit for a

future version.

The movement going into the prototypes is one that's

already deployed in real tool watches in the market, so the

choice is grounded in proven hardware, not experimental.

Appreciate the pointer — definitely worth deeper research

for the future.

commented on Sub-€1000 field-grade tool watch project — looking for honest feedback ·

@Inkitatus — thank you! This is exactly the kind of

structured feedback the project needs at this stage. When

the Rev-B prototype comes back from the lab (July-August)

I'll post a full photo set. Will ping you here. 🤞🍀

commented on Sub-€1000 field-grade tool watch project — looking for honest feedback ·

@sam_kula — thanks, thanks, and thanks. Went and dug into it

right after your message and the info is genuinely good.

Quick summary for anyone else following:

CIRCULA uses 316L steel hardened via Kolsterising (Bodycote's

proprietary low-temperature carbon diffusion process). The

substrate jumps from ~200 HV (regular 316L) to ~1,200 HV.

It's not a coating — it's hardening of the steel's own outer

layer, with no dimensional change and no delamination risk.

On their DLC models (ProTrail), they start from 1,300 HV base

+ DLC on top, which reduces the "eggshell" effect (hard

coating chipping because the substrate underneath is soft).

It's real engineering, not marketing. Coherent philosophy

with Sinn Tegiment, and in a different direction with Damasko

(through-hardened martensitic steel).

Now, honest position: not directly transferable to this

project because the base material is Grade 2 titanium, not

316L. Two distinct philosophies at play:

- Hardening (Circula / Sinn / Damasko): rock-hard substrate,

one surface lifecycle, not recoatable.

- Maintainable coating (this approach): softer substrate,

the coating absorbs the wear, can be field-stripped and

reapplied as routine service.

Both are valid — different objectives. And honestly, I'm

filing away the idea of a possible future hardened-steel +

DLC variant to complement the line. That would compete

directly on Circula/Sinn/Damasko's technical home turf. But

that's outside the scope of the first prototype.

🍻 Thanks for the data point — exactly the kind of input

that's worth gold.

commented on Sub-€1000 field-grade tool watch project — looking for honest feedback ·

@725auto — glad yours is working that well for you. There are

probably different grades of DLC quality on the market, and

yours sounds excellent for that price.

Something often overlooked: design plays a huge role in how

long a coating lasts. In my experience, the first place a

coating fails is on sharp edges — that's where it chips or

peels first. That's why our prototype design uses rounded

lines to avoid snagging, and the sharpest area of the design

has a slightly rounded edge precisely for that reason.

Honest question to the community: do you think we should

consider an automatic version? The planned quartz runs at

±10 to ±20 seconds per year, and it has extra torque for

heavy hands, EOL indicator, etc. It's the movement I

consider optimal for a tool watch — but I'm open to hearing

if there's real demand for an automatic version.

On price: yes, the reality is I'm trying to build it with

the best of everything I can source, and that adds cost.

Swiss Super-LumiNova (not generic), Swiss SL ceramic inserts,

the crystal, the movement, professional-grade coating — every

decision adds cost. The bet is that when you see it and know

it's going to last many years, it'll be worth it. Same logic

on the rest.

Thanks again.

commented on Sub-€1000 field-grade tool watch project — looking for honest feedback ·

@xxDCxx — appreciate that.

Happy to answer honestly anything anyone asks. If I'm holding

some details back, it's because the legal process around the

brand isn't finished yet and I can't say more publicly. The

project has been built in stealth up to this point, and input

from people who actually know watches is what's going to make

it better. That's exactly why I came here.

Thanks to you and to everyone who's taken the time to reply.