TSiWRX

Chieh

0 Posts
1 Followers
0 Following
Follow Following Following
3 weeks ago
Joined
Cleveland, OH, USA
7.50” / 19.05 cm Wrist

Recent Comments

commented on Should you profit off a watch made for charity? ·

^ Thanks @leightond -

I really appreciate your praise and encouragement, and I am blushing because I do not think I deserve it. 😊

Exactly, it's a very nuanced question, and in-particular the way that this watch's original intent was framed makes it even more fraught.

My immediate reactions upon seeing the first ads for this watch was quite conflicted. A fellow hobbyist's suggestion that it's a "death watch" did nag away at me for quite a few nights. In the end, though, it was my own memories of traveling the FSK -my own connections to Baltimore and to Maryland, still- that, combined with Alan promising the proceeds to charity, won the argument. When I wear my Torsk Diver Pro, I am reminded of the many school trips I took there as a child. I know that I'll recall those fond memories every time I even look at my FSK.

Flipping is flipping. I don't begrudge anyone for it. It's a part of virtually every hobby.

And like you, it was the use of Alan's gift to charity that drew my ire.

Why would anyone use the kind gestures of another man as an effective moral shield for their own profiteering? outphase84's words were strong, but I can understand where they were coming from. And if I were the seller, I would have just ignored it - a more confrontational person may have lashed back with a few unkind words themselves. It's only teh int3rwebz. For ancient guys like you and me, we've seen how that coulda either been played out for more attention or extinguished. 😜😂

But instead PresentationNo1716 decided to couch in this rather weird way. I don't see the need for that at all, and I found it to be distasteful enough that I just had to say something about it. "I'm here to make money" is really all that needs to be said...either that, or just let that comment die. But going back to delete that post, I think that in and of itself says something about the seller.

It's a nuanced discussion, and I know that there will be those who don't agree with my view. I also admit to the fact that perhaps my own quite visceral reaction to this is impacted by both my feelings as an owner of the watch (by the reasons why I bought it) as well as my feelings for the first city in America that I called my home. But at the same time, there's also some whose views align with my own.

It's a very interesting discussion - I thank you making this thread, and for paging me to it so that I can better explain my view.

-----

So, the question becomes: "What would I have done," right? 😉

If I didn't need the money, I'd sell it for what I paid for it. I'd let another hobbyist/collector enjoy it just as I have. A lifetime ago I was in the custom knives hobby, and this is how a number of us chose to do it there, and I always thought this was a great thing for my hobby-karma, and I enjoyed being the caretaker of some really cool pieces, at prices that made the hobby sustainable.

If I needed the money?

I'd be up-front about it. I would say that whatever proceeds I got from the sale, I'd do the same as Alan Tsao - I'd donate what I consider fair (let's do the watch at "3x cost?" or "4x cost," if I really were hard-up?). Say the watch sells for $2,500. I deduct my cost, and that's $1K profit. I'd donate $250 of that. I'm happy that I can pay some bills or fund another watch - and I can sleep easy, knowing that the original gesture extended by its maker has been honored.

commented on Should you profit off a watch made for charity? ·

Thanks for the tag-in, @leightond 🙂 This isn't where I usually hang-out, so I do appreciate the page!

There are so many good posts here, with such thoughtful voices. I should hang out here, more.

Me, personally.

I don't have a problem with collectables gaining in price. Even "charity pieces."

I've been a collector of things all my life, and I'd like to think that in having been in this world now for over a half-a-century (yup, I'm old-AF, as my daughter loves to remind me), I'm no longer naive in the way things work. I know that what drives collectibility is in-part scarcity and desirability. There's only 500 of these FSKs, and they're not likely to ever be reprised. I get it, people who have missed them will want them. They are likely to increase in price over time.

The FSK appeals to those of us in the micro community because it's authentic (not just its aesthetics/design but also Alan Tsao's intent for the watch/project). It's got provenance (by way of the many local media articles). It fulfills our desire that the maker undertakes a part of their "watchmaking" in-house or with local partners (which I always find ironic -even though I value the same, myself- as to me the very definition of what makes a microbrand a microbrand is its lack of technical and production capabilities). It has a lot going for it. It's why I bought one, too.

I'm not blind to the likelihood that it'll likely at the very least hold its value.

Do I understand why someone would want to make a profit off anything for which the profits were given to charity? I don't, and I asked the OP there -https://www.reddit.com/r/MicrobrandWatches/comments/1uacoia/tsao_baltimore_francis_scott_key_limited_edition/ - why they wanted to do so. I did it twice, and received no answer. Granted, it was probably the way I couched the question (at close to midnight local after a workday, I probably came off a bit more combative than I should have, but my emotional bond to this watch, I think, caused an understandable knee-jerk reaction in me).....

But eventually we did get an answer: it's because they saw it as "an investment" -



I don't have a problem with that. It's a free country. Your (not you, @leightond , I'm now using "you" to refer to the seller of the FSK in the Reddit thread above) watch. You want to sell it? Charge what you want. Others want it badly enough? They'll pay your premium.

But when someone calls you out for it -



Don't hold up the maker's intent as moral shield.

Had the seller, Redditor PresentationNo1716 , told-off outphase84 with a "It's a free country, brother" or "You don't seem to understand investments" or even a simple "F--k of, yourself." That, I'd have been fine with. Even if he had just let outphase84 's response to-rot, I'd have cared not.

But he didn't.

Don't use the fact that the original watch's profit was given to charity as the moral justification for your doubling its MSRP as your asking price. It's not like you're giving your profits to charity.

To me, that's not cool. That's something that I will stand up against.

And I think that's something that the seller realized, which was why he deleted that particular thread.

Are there other ways to interpret Alan Tsao's intent with the project? Absolutely. I may only have the mental capacity for Checkers or Connect Four, but when someone points out Chess or Go moves to me, I can nod and appreciate it for what it is. But in the end, that money reaches/will reach the ones intended. He made good or will have made good on that promise. The take from this particular seller's piece will simply go to this seller. Which again I'm fine with. I've made IRL friends now in the Reddit community, folks whom I honestly keep in touch with on a daily basis, drooling over our latest pieces or to talk about our family life or careers. Normal people stuff. One such friend texted me a link to PresentationNo1716 's initial sale post, and I sent a thumbs up in-reply. Then I saw what transpired, and it made me a little sad and a little mad, which was why I spoke up.

But in the end, I'm just another watch-nerd, a fellow collector. I'm not the reincarnation of the Dalai Lama. I'm not the pope. I'm not even a Scout leader. It's not like I'm some sort of moral beacon.

I'd just like to see folks call a spade a spade.