Hi Cascalia here:)
Thanks for the review,
he Trustpilot score at the time was 2.8, and it was almost entirely shipping and missing free gifts, not the watch, you read that correctly. It's around 4.3 now on ~270 reviews, and I'm still the one answering them.
it's not a one-person operation. We are two owners and a small team, of around 7 people.
The lifetime warranty is real and we honour it; you're right that a young brand promising "lifetime" deserves a pinch of salt, but we have already shipped out some replacement orders from 15.000 orders.
On the case, the Caratello case is our own tooling, not a catalog case – if you've seen the exact same one on AliExpress I'd like to see it, because it'd mean someone's copying it.
We are definitely not trying to be, nor pretending to be a "highend swiss" brand, we price our watches very low - considering the free shipping which can be 40€+ to some countries given the heavy and large box.
We also honour the lifetime guarantee, and give free straps with every order. So with marketing, salaries and everything taken into consideration, its hard to lower the price any lower than this.
thanks for the review, we appreciate you giving us a chance,
happy to answer any questions you might have.