IIcohow-wowyp duel 3: Casio Duro vs. Smiths Expedition

If I could only have one watch - which one would you chose? Today it's big against small, in multiple ways Casio Duro 45mm of super affordable toolwatch from a beloved big brand or Smiths Expedition 36mm of practical beauty from a microbrand with questionable service anecdotes Choose wisely!
117 votes ·
Reply
·

I already have 1 the Casio Duro or Marlin (if you still have that version). At first I thought oh it’s a little bulky and heavy, but I was wrong it’s great.

·
Daveski

I already have 1 the Casio Duro or Marlin (if you still have that version). At first I thought oh it’s a little bulky and heavy, but I was wrong it’s great.

I too find it quite wearable because it's thin and lightweight. 👍

·

The Casio Duro is simply too large for me.

·

Although I really like the Duro aesthetic, it is too big for me, so even though I don't really like how the Smiths Expedition looks, I would still choose it over a Duro. 

I wish Casio would release a 38mm or 40mm Duro.

·

They should really do a 40mm version. Durolito? Mini-Marlin?

·

Nope. Neither.

·
robwei

They should really do a 40mm version. Durolito? Mini-Marlin?

Wouldn't use the term mini personally. It would only be a bit smaller. Duro 40 would be a cool, although basic, name. Regardless, a 40 mm Duro would be sweet.

·

Even though the Duro has the superior movement, size, color, and numeric indices favor the Expedition.

·

The Smiths for me... but God forbid I ever get reduced to owning one watch! The Expedition in this case seems a more friendly, versatile and physically-forgiving watch over the long term. 

·

I was thinking really, really long. Casio looks really nice, especially with your photo talent. I'm not a huge fan of Smith as a brand, but in the end size and overall dial design prevailed and pushed my vote to Expedition

·

The Duro. I have one. I'm with @chronotriggered on the modern Smiths. No and again No!

·

While I like and own the Duro, I would not want it as my only watch. 

·

Smiths, secondhand.

·

Duro. Or a San Martin homage, whatever it takes to be as physically far away from Smiths. 

·
Image

I’d go with the oil-filled Duro with AliExpress jubilee bracelet and milled-clasp with a date magnifier.