Out of these 3 which one you guys think is the best?

Hi guys I am torn between these 3. It’s going to be my first nice watch and I like them all but can’t decide which one to get. What you think?

Reply
·

Seamaster Diver 300M in green!!!  Damn, that looks the business!

·

I also vote the Seamaster, I feel like it would be the most versatile. Can't go wrong with any of them I think, though personally for me, red would be difficult to pull off with everyday.

·

If you are leaning a little more towards dressy occasions, go with the Aqua Terra. To me, the SMP and BB fit a little better into casual environments due to the design.

·

Red aqua terrace looks like one of those cheap £30 slazenger watches you can find at sports direct imo. Go for the seamaster I suggest

·

I prefer the SMP 300, the colour is subdued, and the styling is more my tastes than the BB.  

·
Mr.Dee.Bater

Seamaster Diver 300M in green!!!  Damn, that looks the business!

Absolutely great watch , love that green.

·

Definitely one of the Omega because of the better movements.

I have an Aqua Terra & Railmaster, and I love them both for there daily wearing capabilities.

The Seamaster is a FABULOUS do-all diver.

That's a tough call.

… I say Seamaster.

·

Seamaster in green would get my vote.

·

You would definitely need to try them on your wrist first and see how they wear for you.

I can tell you which one I prefer the look of, but that won’t tell you which you should get.

They are all good watches. Would a GMT function be often useful to you? Timing stuff with a divers bezel is handy (or if you have problems with a build up of Helium in your watches ;-) . Agree with nytime,  red is less versatile, but don’t let that stop you if you like it

·

I'd go with Tudor 

·

Green looks mean - that's my choice for sure. All pretty nice though. 

·
Mr.Dee.Bater

Seamaster Diver 300M in green!!!  Damn, that looks the business!

Totally agree!

·
doolittle

You would definitely need to try them on your wrist first and see how they wear for you.

I can tell you which one I prefer the look of, but that won’t tell you which you should get.

They are all good watches. Would a GMT function be often useful to you? Timing stuff with a divers bezel is handy (or if you have problems with a build up of Helium in your watches ;-) . Agree with nytime,  red is less versatile, but don’t let that stop you if you like it

Well said!

·

The green Seamaster looks great but who knows if in a few years from now it’s considered faddish and off trend.

If I were in your shoes, I’d go with the Tudor GMT which is more timeless.

But it may be my bias against the Seamaster’s HE escape valve talking.

·

Green Seamaster without a doubt - LOVE IT!

·

As a BIG TIME Tudor fanboy, I would go with the BBGMT. Love Aqua terras, but prefer the horizontal striped dial😉 The green Seamaster looks stunning, and is also an amazing watch. Choose the one that feels rigth to you🌟☺️

·

SMP, in white, if it were my $.  I'm hot a huge fan of this watch in pictures, but I really like it IRL (the weird hands don't bother me nearly as much as I always think they will). 

The AT would be cool in a rotation, but not as your primary watch.

·

I am 1000% all in on the new aqua terra red dial when it lands at retail later this year. Take all my money.

·

Depends on what you already have and what box are you looking to check. The green one is beautiful, and I love the red one, but I just don't think it would be very versatile. 

·

I have the BB GMT, and highly recommend it. But…that red dial on Aqua Terra!  That’s what I would do. 

·
gh0stleader

Tudor still hasn't convinced me that the movement has been fixed. 

What would you have them do, to convince you? They say they have fixed it, and they do have a 5-year warranty, so it is in their best interest to have fixed it.

Personally, the fact that they came out with a new model that will sell like hotcakes, is proof enough for me.

·

I thought the Omega dover was ugly when I saw it in person. I think the Aqua Terra is okay although a bit thick with an underwhelming bracelet.  Never seen the Tudor. 
 

Definitely see and try these on if possible before buying. You may be able to eliminate one or all of these after actually trying them on. 

·
Jeremy

What would you have them do, to convince you? They say they have fixed it, and they do have a 5-year warranty, so it is in their best interest to have fixed it.

Personally, the fact that they came out with a new model that will sell like hotcakes, is proof enough for me.

First, Tudor said they'd fixed it long ago but tons of people were still getting movements that failed repeatedly (check WUS & TRF).

Second, they never gave us an answer as to what the problem was. Whether they wanted to keep the cause of the defect close to their chest for legal reasons or proprietary reasons, the lack of communication doesn't sit right with me.

Third, it doesn't matter how long they've got a warranty on it. If the movement is a lemon, it is doomed to fail. Sure they'll eat the cost of repairs in the beginning but it'll be all out of the customers pocket after the 5 years are up.

Now if putting out a new model is your sign of resolving the defect instead of them trying to make money, good for you...

·

All great choices

love my BB GMT - I like a little extra junk in my trunk and dont mind it thick

Image

the dial changes as you stare at it ♥️♥️♥️
 

plus fun when  traveling to use the GMT feature ✈️
 

good luck with your decision 

·

I'd go with either the Diver 300M or the Tudor. The red AT would hurt my eyes and the finishing on its date window is utter shambles

·

I feel like the red dial aqua terra is suuuuper dressy. Maybe a little too dressy. Like the equivalent to a red felt dress. So maybe go for the Seamaster. 

·

For versatility & everyday wear the Seamaster however, that red is lovely. 

·

I would go with the AquaTerra, I just think it is the most versatile.  But you can't miss with any of the three.

·

Depends what in your collection already, i would recommend the Omega seamaster over the Tudor GMT. Having owned both, although the seamaster is apparently bigger, the lug size and case height are more comfortable vs. The Tudor was way too top heavy, I ended up selling it in the end as was too much for my wrist 

·

Tudor GMT 

because GMT and Pepsi Bezel ✌️